Mbappe Scores 80 Goals in Two Seasons and Wins Back-to-Back Golden Boots, Yet Real Madrid Remain Trophyless; Ballon d'Or Comments Spark Debate

On September 8, 2026, Spanish COPE Radio journalist Juanma Castano raised a topic that is not new but continues to develop: some Madrid fans still have not fully accepted Mbappe. Two seasons, more than 80 goals, a World Cup Golden Boot, and the title of the World Cup's all-time leading scorer are impressive numbers, but the whistles at the Bernabeu have not completely disappeared with new manager Mourinho's arrival.

The issue is not that Mbappe is not good enough, but that the way he succeeds has created an increasingly wider gap with Real Madrid's traditional standards of evaluation.

When he joined as a free agent in the summer of 2024, expectations were that he would be the finisher capable of carrying the team and delivering trophies.

In the 2024-25 season, he scored 44 goals and won the La Liga Golden Boot, but Real Madrid ended the season without any major trophies.

In the 2025-26 season, he won the Golden Boot again with 42 goals, while the team still failed to lift any important trophy.

Individual statistics kept rising while team honors fell to zero, and this contrast itself continued to create a divide.

There were specific moments when the divide deepened.

In April 2026, Mbappe used a club-approved holiday to travel to Sardinia, and his private plane landed only 12 minutes before Real Madrid's match against Espanyol was scheduled to begin.

The incident directly fueled fan anger, and a petition calling for "Mbappe OUT" reportedly surpassed 10 million signatures at one point.

A player enjoying a private plane trip on an important match day created a sharp contrast with the image of Real Madrid predecessors who soaked their shirts with sweat.

Then-manager Arbeloa publicly said: "Real Madrid need players whose shirts are soaked with sweat, not players wearing tuxedos."

This was not just an emotional remark, but a public statement from club management about player professionalism.

In the summer of 2026, Mbappe scored 10 goals at the North America World Cup, raised his World Cup career total to 22 goals to surpass Messi, and won the World Cup Golden Boot for the second consecutive tournament.

France eventually finished fourth, but his individual achievements reached a new level.

After returning to Real Madrid, Mourinho took charge of the team. In his first match, Real Madrid defeated Real Sociedad 4-1 and Mbappe scored a hat-trick.

The new manager fixed Mbappe in the central striker position and focused only on finishing. He scored three goals in the first two La Liga rounds and ranked first in the scoring charts.

From a statistical perspective, everything appeared to be moving in a positive direction.

However, there was also contrary evidence.

During Mourinho's first match back, some fans at the stadium still booed.

The hat-trick did not lead to a stadium-wide chorus of support.

On September 4 in La Liga's fourth round away against Betis, Real Madrid lost 0-1, and Mbappe missed a stoppage-time penalty as the winning streak ended.

A striker who can dominate at home but cannot step up in a key away moment created a contrast that increased doubts again.

On September 7, Mbappe stated at a Champions League pre-match press conference that he was a leading candidate for the 2026 Ballon d'Or, saying "this year may be a good year for me to win it."

The comment came after two trophyless years for the club, and some fans viewed it almost as a provocation.

French legend Dugarry later publicly criticized the behavior as "immature and pitiful," especially from a Real Madrid captain.

Based on current results, Mbappe's desire for top individual honors and Real Madrid fans' belief that a player without trophies should not compete for elite individual awards are no longer just a difference of opinion, but a direct collision between two evaluation systems.

One important background factor is that after Mbappe joined, Bellingham's statistics dropped from 16 goals and 10 assists in his first season to 6 goals and 4 assists later.

This led to questions over whether Mbappe's presence occupied teammates' ball possession and space, damaging the team's attacking structure.

Although this statistical comparison alone cannot prove causation, it aligns with fans' feeling that he has affected the team.

The current evidence only shows that Mbappe's individual explosiveness brings goals to the team, but whether a style centered on individual statistics truly fits Real Madrid's team tradition remains unanswered after two seasons.

The value of COPE Radio's report is that it turned a hidden fan sentiment into a public discussion.

Mourinho's arrival, the hat-trick, and the World Cup records have all failed to close this gap.

Real Madrid currently have six points and sit near the top of La Liga. They will host Inter Milan in the Champions League group stage on September 16, face the Clasico in October, and the Ballon d'Or ceremony will be held in London on October 26.

These moments will test whether the whistles in the stands gradually disappear as the team wins and Mbappe's personal statistics continue to grow, or whether they explode again because of another trophyless campaign.

Fans' acceptance is determined by championships, not the number of goals.

Quality article incentive program